Shavuot: First Edition!

If you haven’t read Shavuot 2020, the prelude, please read it first.

Our modern day Shavuot commemorates Matan Torah (The Giving of the Torah), yet in the Torah, Shavuot is only an agricultural holiday with no mention of Matan Torah or connection to it.

The Torah never says, celebrate a holiday of Shavuot for on that day I gave you the Torah.

Rabbi Joshua ibn Shu’ib (1280-1340) – Sephardic Torah Commentator and Kabbalist

Additionally, the Torah does not provide a date for Matan Torah, so we don’t really know when it occurred. The rabbis chose the 6th of Sivan (on the Hebrew calendar) as the date.

The Torah does not give the date of Matan Torah [giving of the Torah] because the Torah should be new to us every day, as if it were given today.

Rashi (1040 to 1105) – renowned Torah commentator

Every time I introduce Shavuot as an agricultural harvest festival in my shiurim (classes), I get some perplexed responses from Jews who are only familiar with the rabbinical version, (man-made Shavuot), featuring an all night Torah study, cheesecake and blintzes.

I’m into cheesecake and blintzes as much as the next Ashkenazi, but that’s beside the point.

In modern day Israel, Shavuot still retains it’s original meaning as a colorful Harvest Festival celebrating the bounty of the land. Agricultural settlements in Israel (moshavim and kibbutzim) showcase their abundant harvest with parades, music, dancing, farm fresh foods and harvesting ceremonies.

“Shavuot is a big and important event on our kibbutz, and lots of people come to our events from all over the country. Our celebrations include everything, and we put a special significance on our first wheat harvest. The adults of the kibbutz go out into the fields with sickles and scythes to cut and harvest the wheat. Afterwards, we have a huge dairy meal accompanied by dancing.”

Kibbutz Nirim

In the Nesher suburb of Haifa hundreds participate in a first harvest festival on Shavuot which includes a children’s presentation, a farmers market selling cheeses, wine, and olive oil, workshops on basket weaving and wool processing, drum circles, a petting zoo, and donkey rides.

My humble opinion: I would much prefer a Harvest Festival over cramming classes unrelated to the earth’s bounty and eating supermarket cheesecake.

Why not get back to the real Shavuot by offering earth-based workshops? I can think of many that would fit the bill — native gardening, herbalism, hand-crafting, bee-keeping and a fresh smoothie bar!

Instead of supermarket food laden with fat and processed sugar, we could enjoy locally sourced baked goods and dishes made from foods that bless the land of Israel.

For the LORD thy God bringeth thee into a good land, a land of brooks of water, of fountains springing forth; a land of wheat, barley, vines, fig-trees and pomegranates; a land of olive-trees and honey; a land wherein thou shalt eat bread without scarcity…

Devarim/Deuteronomy 8: 7-10

A lively Harvest Festival every year that supports locally sourced food from sustainable farms, hand-crafters, mamma earth, our local economy and our health would be a breath of fresh air, so to speak. I vote for getting back to the roots of Shavuot, literally and spiritually.

©️ 2020 ALL RIGHTS RESERVED – Chochmat Halev (wisdom of the heart) is my ner tamid (eternal light). 

12 thoughts on “Shavuot: First Edition!

      1. Walter F Hernandez

        Amen. Shavuot is agricultural.
        A lot of Jewish teaching and Asian culture use examples on their teachings. What can we learn on nature’s life, many things I believe. Now how my Jewish life will grow when someone non Jewish is teaching? We need back to our roots not wondering in wishful thinking.

        Liked by 3 people

        1. The Wild Pomegranate

          Thank you for reading, sharing your thoughts and adding your voice to the conversation, Walter! You made very good points! I learned something new — I didn’t know that about Asian culture.

          Liked by 2 people

  1. Yaffa N

    I agree wholeheartedly! I make homemade soap and grow my own vegetables and fruit. I try to present that on Shavuot many a moon at the local synagogue and my ideas were rejected. They were replaced with store bought cheesecake and teachers who did not even teach the concepts of Shavuot and half of the teachers were not even Jewish. I concur that we should get back to the roots!

    Liked by 2 people

    1. The Wild Pomegranate

      I’m not at all surprised they didn’t listen to you. I know exactly what you mean. Sigh. Big-box houses of worship are the problem — they’ve turned religion into a business and a brand with a select few macherimin in charge. It’s a sell-out.

      Thank you for being here on this journey with me. Your voice is important and very much appreciated.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Phil Sutherland

    I believe that the giving of Torah is a very significant event. But, while it is a guide for our lives, and we should study Torah, the significance of the provision of G-d to me is far more important. After all, the Jews just got done wandering in the desert where their very lives were dependent upon G-d providing, and they finally arrived at a point where they once again were able to grow and harvest their own food. They needed to thank G-d for his abundant supply. They had learned the lessons of hardship where they became dependent upon G-d, grumbling about wanting to go back to Egypt, and had to continue in the wandering until they learned the lesson that G-d wanted them to learn, a very hard taught lesson, that nothing that they have is from their efforts, but, from the gift of G-d. They need to have a time of reflection on the gifts given to them in His provision, which does include Torah, but, should not be the only focus.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. The Wild Pomegranate

      Beautifully expressed! It would a happy medium if they celebrated both meanings, the original and the rabbinical, by offering earth-based classes, foods and workshops on Shavuot imbued with the spirit of the harvest festival. We need time to reflect on mother earth’s bounty and gratitude for our sustainable farmers, just as much as the ancient Israelites did. Great thoughts! Thank you for joining the conversation.

      Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s